Contact Us

    Welcome to Pence Family Dentistry!

    Dr. Orey Pence & Dr. E. Dale Behner

    At our practice in Indianapolis, we want our patients to feel like family. Dr. Pence’s skill, dedication, and compassion allow our patients to feel confident and secure in the knowledge that they are receiving the best possible care for their teeth. We utilize cutting-edge technology, education, and innovation to provide meaningful dental services in Indianapolis. Our team believes that great health begins with a healthy smile, but we also do whatever we can to promote your health in other areas as well. We will work with you individually to ensure your optimal oral health and will do whatever we can to make sure that every patient who enters our office walks out feeling better.

    Our Services

    Sedation Dentistry

    Sedation dentistry allows any patient to feel relaxed and calm during any of our procedures. Patients who have been avoiding the dentist don’t have to let dental anxiety keep them from getting the dental care that they need. We offer a full range of sedation dentistry options including oral conscious sedation, laughing gas, and IV sedation. Even if you’ve suffered from dental anxiety in the past, you can enjoy your dental visits in the future with a pre-appointment sedation dentistry treatment. Learn More

    Dental Implants

    We hope that our patients can enjoy a full natural smile for the rest of their lives. However, for patients who have suffered from tooth loss due to accident, decay, or other tragedy, we offer beautiful, state-of-the-art dental implants that provide a perfect replacement for that lost tooth. Dr. Pence and Dr. Behner are skilled in both placing implants and restoring dental crowns or other implant restorations. If you’ve lost a tooth, it doesn’t have to be the end of your full, beautiful smile. Learn More

    Integrative Dentistry

    Integrative dentistry services provide a natural and holistic approach to conventional dentistry techniques. At our practice, we use meaningful holistic services to encourage great oral health, and a better general, overall well-being. If you’re interested in maintaining a healthy oral environment through organic treatments, our integrative dentistry treatments can help you achieve your goals, and give you a better understanding of your health related needs. Learn More

    Cosmetic Dentistry

    At Pence Family Dentistry, we understand that a beautiful smile can be the ultimate accessory. Thanks to our cosmetic procedures such as Invisalign clear aligners, teeth whitening, porcelain veneers, and more, we can give our patients the smile they’ve always wanted. Our patients can feel proud of their teeth, and more confident in social situations after one of our cosmetic dentistry procedures. At our practice, we can enhance your smile and help your natural beauty shine. Learn More


    I had put off having dental work because of anxiety. I’m so glad to have been referred to Dr. Behner many years ago. Being able to have IV sedation enabled me to get the work done that was needed. Dr. Behner and his staff are so understanding. My bite is better due to crowns and I’m no longer in pain. Thank you, Dr. Behner. I no longer “dread” the dentist.

    —Leslee D.

    Dr. Behner and his staff and just the best. They are worth my families 1-hour drive!

    —Harry B.

    My experince with Dr. Behner and staff seriously changed my life. I’m 52, and feared the dentist since childhood, after terrible visits. Over 5 years ago, I found Dr. Behner after doing an internet search for sedation dentistry. At my first visit, even before my sedation appt., I knew I had found my dentist for life. The atmosphere, the staff, and the dentist, all give a sense of comfort and peace. I’ve never once been afraid again, and actually look forward to my appointments!

    —Cindy M.

    Dr's Behner and Pence provide an outstanding service and I am glad they are my dentist. Their staff is awesome also.

    —Pat S.

    Dr. Behner runs a fantastic and very professional practice. His Dental Hygienist did a wonderful and pain-free cleaning. Always an excellent experience!

    —Greg M.

    I know I need some extra pats and such to get me ready, and they always have been there to smile and reassure me! It’s extremely embarrassing to have so much fear but they are there not judging by comforting me!

    —Jeanie M.

    The entire staff is so kind and considerate that over the years my anxiety has diminished. They are my "dental family". Just had an extraction and cannot imagine a better dentist!

    —Judy S.


    Call Today

    To find out more about our services, or to schedule an appointment. Call us at our Fishers office today! Dr. Pence, Dr. Behner, and their staff serve patients from all over the Indianapolis area, including Fishers, Carmel, Noblesville, Pendleton, McCordsville, and Lawrence!

    Contact Us

      9744 Lantern Rd Fishers, IN 46037


      Text message is limited to 160 characters.


      1. Enter your Name.
      2. Enter your Cell Phone Number, area code first
      3. Enter your text message in the box.
      4. Click "Send Text"
      5. A copy of this text will be sent to the office and to your cell phone. The office's reply will also be sent to your cell phone where you can continue the text conversation.
      Note: Mobile message and data rates from your cell phone carrier may apply.Close ClickToCall Button
      NagiosCheckValue - Do not remove please