Meet Dr. Orey Pence

Dr. Orey Pence

Dr. Orey Pence, DDS

Dr. Pence is a Noblesville native and 2005 Noblesville High School graduate. His dental career started over ten years ago when he was accepted into the dental hygiene program at Indiana University School of Dentistry earning an Associate of Science Degree in Dental Hygiene in 2009 followed by a Bachelor of Science Degree in Dental Hygiene Public Health in 2010. After practicing clinical dental hygiene for 5 years, Orey resumed studies at Indiana University School of Dentistry receiving a Doctor of Dental Surgery degree in the spring of 2018. Some of you may have had the opportunity to experience his comforting manner and excellent skills while filling in as a substitute hygienist in our office.

Dr Pence is excited to be a full time member of the team at Dental Care Today so that he may help patients achieve and maintain optimal oral health. He strongly believes that oral health is only one component of a more holistic approach to overall well-being and strives to accomplish that for his patients through minimally invasive dentistry. Dr. Pence currently resides in Fishers with his beautiful and loving wife Christy and their two mischievous pups: Pickles and Rudy. They both enjoy spending time with friends and family. Dr. Pence abhors all things related to exercise, is a proud Hoosier, Colts fan, and wannabe gearhead.

Please call 317-842-2337 to schedule appointments.

New Patient Offer
Contact Us





    View our privacy policy


    Harry B.

    Dr. Behner and his staff and just the best. They are worth my families 1-hour drive!

    —Harry B.

    Greg M.

    Dr. Behner runs a fantastic and very professional practice. His Dental Hygienist did a wonderful and pain-free cleaning. Always an excellent experience!

    —Greg M.

    Pat S.

    Dr's Behner and Pence provide an outstanding service and I am glad they are my dentist. Their staff is awesome also.

    —Pat S.

    Jeanie M.

    I know I need some extra pats and such to get me ready, and they always have been there to smile and reassure me! It’s extremely embarrassing to have so much fear but they are there not judging by comforting me!

    —Jeanie M.

    Leslee D.

    I had put off having dental work because of anxiety. I’m so glad to have been referred to Dr. Behner many years ago. Being able to have IV sedation enabled me to get the work done that was needed. Dr. Behner and his staff are so understanding. My bite is better due to crowns and I’m no longer in pain. Thank you, Dr. Behner. I no longer “dread” the dentist.

    —Leslee D.

    Cindy M.

    My experince with Dr. Behner and staff seriously changed my life. I’m 52, and feared the dentist since childhood, after terrible visits. Over 5 years ago, I found Dr. Behner after doing an internet search for sedation dentistry. At my first visit, even before my sedation appt., I knew I had found my dentist for life. The atmosphere, the staff, and the dentist, all give a sense of comfort and peace. I’ve never once been afraid again, and actually look forward to my appointments!

    —Cindy M.

    Judy S.

    The entire staff is so kind and considerate that over the years my anxiety has diminished. They are my "dental family". Just had an extraction and cannot imagine a better dentist!

    —Judy S.


    If you are searching for an Indianapolis dentist to provide cosmetic dentistry, sedation dentistry, or dental implants, Dr. E. Dale Behner is here for you! Call today to schedule an appointment if you are in the area, including Fishers and Carmel. Dental Care Today PC - E. Dale Behner DDS
    9744 Lantern Rd
    Fishers, IN 46037
    Call: 317-842-2337317-842-2337
    Write a Review
    Review Us on Google Review Us on Facebook Review Us on Angies List
    Connect With Us
    Best Dentists in Indianapolis
    Top 10 dentists in Fishers, IN
    Dr. Elton D. Behner, DDS has been awarded as a top Dentistry practice with some of Fishers's best Dentists.
    Verified by
    NagiosCheckValue - Do not remove please